Honestly, I believe the first time I heard of a Chicken Finger Pizza was here in Buffalo. I remember ordering chicken on pizza, but it was never chicken fingers. I mean that's basically a whole other order, right? But God bless Buffalo for taking two entrees and combining them into one delicious dish! The pizzerias below have 4-star ratings or better and are listed in no particular order. If I left your fav off the list, leave a comment and let me know. Bone apple tea!

1. Fatman's Pizza
Fatman's is located at 2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda, NY 14150.

Fatman's Pizza aims to be local, fresh and new with every item on the menu. Using WNY staples such as cup-n-char pepperoni, Frank's hot sauce, Scapelliti's homemade sausage, and the freshest produce possible, Fatman's Pizza fills that Buffalo blueprint for great food. ~Fatman's Pizza

It has a 4.5-star rating on Google.

Zack Kociszewski left a 5-star review on Google,

Only ordered here a few times because I just found out about them. Great pizza wings and subs and very fair prices. Highly recommend 👍

Thomas Summers also gave Fatman's 5 stars,

I’ve ordered from Fatman’s multiple times over the past year or so and haven’t had a bad meal, ever! The sauce on the pizza is exceptional and their speciality pizzas and menu items are just as good. Fair prices and a friendly staff! 5/5 stars.

The chicken finger pizza at Fatman's comes with your choice of fingers and bleu cheese sauce. You can check out the full menu here.

2. Santora's Pizza Pub & Grill
The location we're recommending is at 7800 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221. Santora's has two other locations, but the Transit restaurant has 4.3-stars on Google.

Santora's Pizza originated in 1927 and was the first pizza sold in Buffalo, NY. The same quality and freshness goes into every pizza we sell! ~ Santora's Pizza Pub & Grill

Santora's Buffalo Chicken Pizza features sauce covered with chopped chicken fingers (medium), bleu and mozzarella cheese, celery, and parsley. You can find the full menu here.

3. La Nova

La Nova, located at 371 W Ferry St, Buffalo, NY 14213, boasts a 4.2-star rating on Google.

Trever Welch reviewed its Chicken Finger Pizza on Google,

Chicken fingers on the Buffalo chicken was the best idea definetly recommend any of their pizza

Cari C gave the La Nova Chicken Finger Pizza 5-stars,

I ordered a chicken finger pizza, one half with extra cheese and added broccoli. The slices were big, the pizza was very big, the crust was perfect, the extra cheese half of the pizza was so cheesy and delicious. Delivery was quick and pizza was still hot. 20/10 would recommend. Was so delicious.

A La Nova Chicken Finger Pizza sounds pretty tasty,

Blue cheese base with a spicy crust. Topped with La Nova chicken fingers, fontinella, cheddar, and 100% pure mozzarella cheeses. ~ La Nova


View the full menu here.

4. Gino's NY Pizzeria Elmwood

Gino's is located at 1009 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222. It has 4.3 stars on Google. Gino's Chicken Finger Pizza starts with a bleu cheese base, which is covered with chicken fingers and your choice of wing sauce (hot, medium or mild).

You can see Gino's full menu here.

5. Lovejoy Pizzeria
It's located at 900 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14202. It has a 4.3-star Google rating.

Andrew S gave their Chicken Finger Pizza a 5-star rating on Google,

A hidden gem, mostly. I don't think I've ever had a better chicken finger pie and their wings are always well done. I could dock a star for them not doing any app-based order taking, but it's really part of the charm. Sometimes the phone will ring 20 times, forward to another line, then ring another 10 times before an annoyed man who is speaking through a can on a string takes your order. Feels like the good old days. Universal truth of pizzerias: the more godawful the phone system, the better the pizza. Just do it, it's so worth it.

cody longwell agrees,

Thee best chicken finger pizza I’ve ever had. Great subs too. Highly recommend.

Lovejoy's "Chicken Finger Pie" as they call it consists of bleu cheese, mozzarella, chicken fingers made with your choice of sauce (mild, medium, hot, or BBQ). You can take a look at the full menu here.

6. Sports City Pizza Pub
Located at 1407 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14213, Sports City has a 4.5-star rating on Google. It offers three variations of the Chicken Finger Pizza,

-Buffalo Chicken:
Tender Chicken Finger, wing sauce, Bleu Cheese, and Mozzarella
Choice of Hot, Medium, Mild

-Southern BBQ Chicken:
Southern BBQ Chicken PizzaBBQ base, Tender BBQ Chicken Finger, Mozzarella & Cheddar, topped with Smokehouse Bacon…

-Steak & Finger
100% Olive Oil & Italian Seasoning, Sirloin Steak, Tender Chicken Fingers, topped with 3 Cheeses ~ Sports City Pizza Pub

Check out the full menu here.

7. Bob & John's La Hacienda
It is located at 1545 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216. Bob & John's has 4.3-stars on Google.

Alex Moskal, a local guide on Google, gives its Chicken Finger Pizza 5-stars,

Chicken Finger Pizza. Best in the business.

Roberto Arana gives the restaurant 5-stars, but issues a warning about parking,

Chicken finger pizza was delicious as well as onion soup crock. Good location but poor parking

Bob & John's makes its Chicken Finger Pizza from,

Bleu cheese sauce, mozzarella cheese, and chicken fingers. Fingers shook mild, medium or hot. ~ Bob & John's La Hacienda

Take a look at the full menu here.

8. Imperial Pizza
Located at 1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220, Imperial has 4.5-stars on Google.

Its "Stinger Pizza" is made up of,

Blue Cheese or Traditional Red Sauce with Chopped Steak and Chicken Fingers w/ melted Cheese ~ Imperial Pizza

Joseph left a review on Imperial's website saying,

The Stinger Pizza was abaolutely amazing with the traditional red sauce. Plenty of protein, and the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Would highly recommend!

Firegems also left some love on its website,

Loved the traditional cheese pepperoni..but the Stinger is at a whole new level..over the top! Delicious!

It also offers a just Chicken Finger Pizza which features cheese and chicken fingers with your choice of sauce (Hot, Medium, Mild, Plain or BBQ).

You can find the full menu here.

9. Bocce Club Pizza

Bocce Club Pizza has several locations, but we're listing the store located at 4174 Bailey Ave, Amherst, NY 14226, which has a 4.2-star Google rating.

It offers a Chicken Finger Pizza and a "kind of" Chicken Finger Pizza,

- Lizzy's Chicken Finger Pizza
Wing sauce (hot, med, mild) American, cheddar, mozzarella cheese, chicken fingers and blue cheese

- Terri's Chicken Pie
Mozzarella cheese, Romano cheese and tender chicken strips tossed in your favorite wing sauce (hot, med, mild) ~ Bocce Club Pizza

93.7 WBLK logo
Get our free mobile app

Western New Yorkers Favorite Wing Sauce Besides Hot, Medium, Or Mild

Thinking about going on a wing adventure check out some of the outside-the-box wing sauces.

7 Places To Get Birch Beer In Western New York

When I was thinking about Birch Beer, I realized is that you really don't see it anywhere in Western New York anymore

7 Restaurants in Buffalo with Must-Try Mac and Cheese

More From 93.7 WBLK