Who’s Right in This Scenario? [QOTD]

So I ran across this meme the other day and I've been trying to figure out the answer. I've been racking my brain and this has me very vexed!

#QuestionsThatNeedAnswers lol but seriously tho, who's right? #QOTD

A photo posted by Ed-Nice (@djednice) on May 14, 2016 at 5:09am PDT

So is this a true statement? If so, who's right in this situation?

I need to know?! Let's talk about it!